Pick by what he already likes
Look at what he snacks on after dinner and what he wears on Saturdays, then give him the better version.
If he really means "nothing"
- Give him something he'll use up. A treat doesn't need a spot in the garage.
- Give him time. Plan a breakfast or a game together, and put it in the card.
- From the grandkids: let them choose the flavor and hand it over themselves.
- Write one line in the card about something he taught you. That's the part he keeps.